Department of the Legislative Assembly, Northern Territory Government

Minutes of Proceedings - 2000-06-13

Eighth Assembly First Session 13/06/2000 Parliamentary Record No. 23
__________________________________________________________________________________

Date : 13/06/2000
__________________________________________________________________________________
Index to Minutes – 13 June 2000 to 22 June 2000
EIGHTH ASSEMBLY - FIRST SESSION

From To Pages
13 June 200022 June 2000 693 - 741

Bold No. 123=Passed Bill
Italic & Bold No. 123=Discharged Bill
Italic No. 123=Negatived Bill

BILLS
    Appropriation (Adelaide to Darwin Railway) Bill 2000 (Serial 251) 718
    Appropriation Bill 2000 – 2001 (Serial 233) 722, 727, 731, 733
    AustralAsia Railway (Special Provisions) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 238) 733, 740
    AustralAsia Railway Corporation Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 239) 733, 740
    Crown Lands Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 250) 694, 706
    Education Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 224) 706
    Energy Pipelines Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 245) 700, 712
    Financial Relations Agreement (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2000 (Serial 228) 714
    First Home Owner Grant Bill 2000 (Serial 229) 714
    Health Practitioners and Allied Professionals Registration Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 227) 707
    International Transfer of Prisoners (Northern Territory) Bill 2000 (Serial 232) 698
    Land Title (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2000 (Serial 248) 694, 706
    Law of Property (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2000 (Serial 249) 694, 706
    Legal Practitioners Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 242) 712
    Mandatory Sentencing Repeal Bill 2000 (Serial 216) 704
    Mine Management Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 225) 705
    Mining Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 243) 696, 698
    Miscellaneous (Interpretation Act and Penalties Act) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 237) 696
    Motor Accidents (Compensation) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 221) 707
    Pay-Roll Tax Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 235) 714
    Petroleum Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2000 (Serial 246) 700, 712
    Petroleum Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 244) 696, 698
    Registration of Teachers Bill 2000 (Serial 223) 705
    Retail Tenancies Bill 2000 (Serial 218) 704
    Stamp Duty Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 240) 714
    Taxation (Administration) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 241) 714
    Work Health Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2000 (Serial 247) 700, 712
    Work Health Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 236) 718

CENSURE
    Ministers for Primary Industry and Fisheries (Mr Palmer) and Lands, Planning and
    Environment (Mr Baldwin) re King Ash Bay Fishing Club planning issues (Mrs Hickey) 710

CONDOLENCES
    William (Bill) James McLaren, AM Commissioner of the Northern Territory Police
    from 1967 to October 1978 (Mr Burke) (Paper 1861) 694

GENERAL BUSINESS DAY
    Wednesday 14 June 2000 701

LEAVE OF ABSENCE
    Mr Rioli, sittings 13 June 2000 to 22 June 2000 (Ms Martin) 695


MEMBER SUSPENDED
    Mr Stirling, 14 June 2000 at 1829 h, one hour pursuant to Standing Order 240A 703

MESSAGES FROM ADMINISTRATOR
    No. 23 assent to proposed laws, March 2000 (Paper 1860) 693
    No. 24 Assent to proposed laws May 2000 and June 2000 (Paper 1875) 699
    No. 25 recommending Appropriation (Adelaide to Darwin Railway) Bill 2000 (Paper 1900) 709
    No. 26 recommending the First Home Owner Grant Bill 2000 (Paper 1909) 715
    No. 27 re AustralAsia Railway Corporation Amendment Bill 2000 733

MOTIONS (Procedural)
    Suspension of Standing Orders
    Pass Bills through all stages
      Miscellaneous (Interpretation Act and Penalties Act) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 237),
      Mining Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 243), Petroleum Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 244),
      Legal Practitioners Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 242), Work Health Amendment Bill 2000
      (Serial 236), Health Practitioners and Allied Professionals Registration Amendment Bill
      2000 (Serial 227), Financial Relations Agreement (Consequential Provisions) Bill
      (Serial 228), First Home Owner Grant Bill 2000 (Serial 229), Pay-roll Tax Amendment
      Bill 2000 (Serial 235), Stamp Duty Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 240), Taxation
      (Administration) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 241), AustralAsia Railway (Special
      Provisions) Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 238), AustralAsia Railway Corporation
      Amendment Bill 2000 (Serial 239) 695

MOTIONS (Substantive)
    Aboriginal Reconciliation (Ms Martin) 694, 702
    Agriculture and Horticultural industry developments in Katherine region –
    Note statement (Mr Palmer) 695
    APEC Trade Ministers Conference in Darwin – Note statement (Mr Manzie) 711
    Department of Local Government 1998/99 – Performance Report - Note statement (Mrs Braham) 695
    GST Impact on Tax Zone Rebate (Ms Martin) 694, 701
    Indonesia, changes for the better – Note statement (Mr Burke) 711
    Museums and Art Galleries of the Northern Territory, Cultural and Scientific Research
    undertaken – Note statement (Mr Adamson) 700
    NTETA role and directions of the Northern Territory’s Education and Training facility –
    Note statement (Mr Lugg) 712
    Sale of the Northern Territory TAB – Note statement (Mr Baldwin) 700
    Suspension of sitting, Tuesday 20 June 2000 - Further consideration in Committee of the
    Whole (Mr Palmer) 725
    Suspension of sitting, Wednesday 21 June 2000 - Further consideration in Committee of
    the Whole (Mr Palmer) 729

PAPERS TABLED
    Aboriginal Community Housing Stock (Paper 1969) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Aboriginal Housing Business Division, administrative support (Paper 1972) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Aboriginal Regional Councils in the Territory (Paper 1970) (MrsBraham) 732
    Annual Reports
    Centralian College, 31 December 1999 (Paper 1958) 740
    Cobourg Peninsula Sanctuary and Marine Park Board 1998/99 (Paper 1959) 740
    Department of Local Government 1998/99 – Performance Report (Paper 1866) (Mrs Braham) 695
    Nitmiluk National Park, Year ended 30 June 1999 (Paper 1960) 740
    Northern Territory Legal Aid Commission, 1998/99 (Paper 1930) 740
    Road Safety Council of the Northern Territory, 1998/99 (Paper 1859) 698
    Answer to question by Ms Martin – Outcomes of securing major new international investments
    in the Territory economy, Department of Asian Relations and Trade (Paper 1942) (Mr Manzie) 727
    Answer to question by Ms Martin – Outcomes of strategic new regional and country markets
    1999-00, Department of Asian Relations and Trade (Paper 1941) (Mr Manzie) 727
    APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade Meeting Darwin June 6-7, 2000 List of Ministers
    present (Paper 1907) (Mr Manzie) 711
    APEC statement of the Chair, Darwin, 7 June 2000 (Paper 1908) (Mr Manzie) 711
    Appropriation Bill 2000/2001 N T Attorney-General’s Department – Questions and Answers -
    Table 1, Native Title Matters, expenditure (Paper 1931) (Mr Burke) 723
    Appropriation Bill 2000/2001 N T Attorney-General’s Department – Questions and Answers -
    Table 2, Land Rights Matters, expenditure (Paper 1932) (Mr Burke) 723
    Artists in the Fields a retrospective by Museums and Art Gallery of the Northern Territory
    (Paper 1880) 700
    Australian Artists and the Northern Territory (Paper 1884) 700
    Australian Declaration toward Reconciliation (Paper 1863) (Mr Burke) 694
    Birds of the Parliamentary Precinct, Darwin, Northern Territory (Paper 1978) (Mr Reed) 740
    Breakdown of Advertising Expenses (Paper 1940) (Mr Baldwin) 724
    Budget 2000, Delivering Quality Services, Jobs and Lifestyle, Northern Territory News,
    dated 20 June 2000 (Paper 1934) (Mr Reed) 724
    Cabinet Submission on privatisation of PAWA, Extract of (Paper 1901) (Ms Martin) 709
    Chief Minister – Summary of Interstate Nominees Travel 1 July 1999 to 31 May 2000
    (Paper 1924) (Mr Burke) 722
    Chief Minister – Summary of Overseas Nominees Travel 1 July 1999 to 31 May 2000
    (Paper1925) (Mr Burke) 722
    Contemporary Territory 1998 – Third Biennial Exhibition of Northern Territory, 4 July –
    23 August 1998 (Paper 1881) 700
    Crown Lands Act
    Revocation of Purkiss Memorial Reserve No. 1534, over Lot 294 Town of
    Tennant Creek (Paper 1980) 740
    Curtin University of Technology, National Drug Research Institute, preventing harmful
    drug use in Australia, (Paper 1916) 721
    Dental Services detail of waiting lists, staff vacancies and expenditure by region 1999/2000
    (Paper 1954) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Department of the Chief Minister, 1 July 1999 to 31 May 2000 – functions by date and
    Minister (Paper 1926) (Mr Burke) 722
    Development of Land and Water Resources in Ti Tree (Paper 1984) (Mr Baldwin) 725
    Discussion Paper and invitation to comment – Proposal for a New Mine Management Act
    by Northern Territory Government, Department of Mines and Energy (Paper 1897) (Mr Manzie) 705
    Dwellings sold under the Housing 2003 policy by stock, type and area (Paper 1973) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Education is not GST – free by Michael Lee MP Shadow Minister for Education Canberra,
    dated 8 June 2000 (Paper 1962) (Mr Toyne) 731
    Eisteddfod, 39th North Australian (Paper 1979) (Mr Adamson) 740
    Emerging from What by Deana Murray (Paper 1885) 700
    Enhancements to Police Housing, actual expenditure 1999-2000, programmed expenditure
    2000-2001 by location (Paper 1937) (Mr Reed) 724
    Expenditure Details by individual Minister – Document Production (Paper 1928) (Mr Burke) 722
    Expenditure Details by individual Minister - Entertainment (Paper 1922) (Mr Burke) 722
    Expenditure Details by individual Minister – Marketing and Promotion (Paper 1927) (Mr Burke) 722
    Expenditure on Awards for 2000-2001, Department of the Chief Minister (Paper 1921) (Mr Burke) 722
    Extreme Landforms by Christian Clare Robertson 14 November 1997 to 19 April 1998 (Paper 1882) 700
    Financial Management Act
    Direction by the Treasurer, pursuant to section 20(1)(a) - Transfer of Excess Allocations
    between Activities, dated 15 June 2000 (Paper 1956) 741
    Foundation initiatives (including a progress report) (Paper 1965) (Mr Adamson) 732
    Funding for Recreation Officers in Aboriginal Communities 1999-2000 (Paper 1955) (Mr Lugg) 729
    Funding to town camp organisations 1999-2000 (Paper 1967) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Golden Chef’s Hat Award, List of Competitors (Paper 1983) (Mrs Braham) 712
    Government Agencies housing construction costs on Aboriginal Communities
    (Paper 1976) (Mrs Braham) 733
    Graph 1 Percentage of Northern Territory Population Covered by Hospital Insurance
    Tables (Paper 1952) (Mr Dunham) 728
    GST to hit NT drivers, Northern Territory News, dated 14 June 2000 (Paper 1872) 700
    Housing costs 1999-2000 (Paper 1968) (Mrs Braham) 732
    IHANT Pooled Housing Funds (Paper 1891)(Mrs Braham) 703
    Incidence of Unlawful Entry by Regional Centre 1998-99 to 199 – 31 May 2000
    (Paper 1936) (Mr Reed) 724
    Indigenous Education Strategic Education Program – Collins Review recommendations
    (Paper 1961) (Mr Lugg) 731
    Interstate Transfers and Patient Costs by Specialty 1999 – 2000 (financial year to date)
    (Paper 1951) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Labour Hire Companies and Companies providing Independent Contractors by Agency,
    Company engaged, purpose and cost (Paper 1938) (Mr Reed) 724
    Lands Acquisition Act
    Statement of reasons for Acquisition, pursuant to section 44(3A) Re
      AustralAsia Railway Project re easement over Section 4047 Strangways, Section 4048
      Hundred of Strangways (Paper 1862) 698
    Leased Property by Agency, location, period of lease and Owner (Paper1939) (Mr Reed) 724
    Letters
    Burke, Hon D, Chief Minister to Hon Kim Beazley, Leader of the Opposition
    dated 22 May 2000 (Paper 1910) 721
    Carpenter, Mr G, Land and business Agent to Hon M Reed MLA, Minister for Tourism,
    dated 5 April 1997 (Paper 1982) (Mrs Hickey) 710
    Coles, Mr David to Mr Lindsay Turner, Chairman Nyirripi Community (Paper 1871) 698
    Manzie, Hon D W to Mr S Stirling MLA re New Mine Management Act,
    dated 24 February 2000 (Paper 1894) (Mr Manzie) 705
    Unnamed to Hon D Manzie re Petroleum Exploration Permits, dated 26 August 1999
    (Paper 1945) (Mr Manzie) 727
    unsigned to Honourable Denis Burke, Chief Minister, re NTIS Director
    Mr Dennis Hatcher (Paper 1920) (Ms Martin) 721
    List of costed promises by Leader of the Opposition to the Budget 2000 –2001
    (Paper 1911) (Mr Reed) 721
    List of Current Joint Projects being pursued by Natural Sciences Research Staff of the
    Museums and Art Galleries of the NT (Paper 1981) 701
    List of enterprises and their activities currently operating out of the Trade Development
    Zone, including employment numbers (Paper 1944) (Mr Manzie) 727
    List of IHANT projects in the Barkly Region (Paper 1975) (Mrs Braham) 733
    Local Government Funding, Grants and Subsidies 1999-2000 to 2000 to 2001
    (Paper 1966) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Martin Luther King Day, speech I have a dream, 28 August 1963 (Paper 1893)(Mr Elferink) 703
    Mining and Exploration Titles affected by Native Title – June 2000 (Paper 1943) (Mr Manzie) 727
    Nursing Homes and Hostels Aged Residential Care Allocations and Wait Lists as at
    13 June 2000 (Paper 1953) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Ombudsman's Report re section 17A preliminary inquiry report complaint against Territory
    Health Services (THS) by Ms Clare Martin, MLA Leader of the Opposition by Peter A Boyce,
    Ombudsman (Paper 1902) (Mr Dunham) 709
    Overseas Travel Comparison 1998/99 and 1999/01 expenses incurred by each Minister
    (Paper 1923) (Mr Burke) 722
    Police Administration Act
    Consent Agreement, Superintendent Salaries, pursuant to section 51,
    dated 22 May 2000 (Paper 1868) 698
    Press release COGSO and Independent Education Union of Australia, Discussion Paper
    (Paper 1898) (Mr Henderson) 705
    Pulse Jacki Fleet (Paper 1883) 700
    Receipts of sale of homes under Housing 2003 by area (Paper 1974) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Regulations 2000
    No. 24 Amendments of Procurement Regulations (Paper 1887) 707
    No. 25, Amendment of Consumer Affairs and Fair Trading (Pawnbrokers and
    Second-Hand Dealers) Regulations (Paper 1869) 698
    No. 26, Legislative Assembly (Powers and Privileges) Regulations (Paper 1870) 698
    No. 27, Totalisator Licensing and Regulation Regulations (Paper 1912) 741
    No. 28, Totalisator Licensing and Regulation (Arbitration) Regulations (Paper 1913) 741
    No. 29, Totalisator Licensing and Regulation (Hearings) Regulations (Paper 1914) 741
    No. 30, Amendments of Racing and Betting Regulations (Paper 1915) 741
    Report to Parks Australia North, on the Estuarine Fish inventory of Kakadu National Park,
    Northern Territory, Australia by Helen K Larson (Paper 1879) 700
    Resignations in each rural health clinic by category of staff and as a percentage of total staff
    in each category (Paper 1950) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Resignations in each Territory Hospital by category of staff and as a percentage of total staff
    in each category (Paper 1949) (MrDunham) 728
    Roadmap for Reconciliation (Paper 1864) (Mr Burke) 694
    Schedule of Elective Surgery Waiting List – Census by month of all five Territory Hospitals
    1999-00 (Paper 1947) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Schedule of teacher resignations by month and region (Paper 1957) (Mr Lugg) 731
    Schedule, Hospital Emergency Department Waiting Times (Minutes) by Triage Category
    July 1999 to May 2000 (Paper 1946) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Skinks of the Northern Territory by Paul Horner (Paper 1876) 700
    Sorry Business Focus Corroboree 2000 Special Report, Weekend Australian,
    dated 27 May 2000 (Paper 1892) (Mr Ah Kit) 703
    Sponsorships Paid (Annual Report) for period 1 July 1999 to 30 June 2000
    (Paper 1964) (Mr Adamson) 732
    Strategies to improve employment opportunities and outcomes for Aboriginal people
    (Paper 1986) (Mrs Braham) 732
    Strategy, Aboriginal Economic Development Model (Paper 1977) (Mrs Braham) 733
    Surgical category average waiting times on waiting lists for all five Territory Hospitals 1999-00
    (Paper 1948) (Mr Dunham) 728
    Syd’s Column, Arafura Times, dated 15 December 1999 re Work Health and Mine Management
    Acts (Paper 1895) (Mr Manzie) 705
    Syd’s Column, Arafura Times, dated 23 February 2000 re Work Health and Mine Management
    Acts (Paper 1896) (Mr Manzie) 705
    Territory Capital Works Projects 2000 – 2001, Schedule of (Paper 1985) (Mr Palmer) 728
    Territory Housing cost by program item (Paper 1971) (Mrs Braham) 732
    The Beagle – Records of the Museums and Art Galleries of the Northern Territory,
    Vol 15 December 1999 (Paper 1878) 700
    The Marine Flora and Fauna of Darwin Harbour, Northern Australia (Paper 1877) 700
    The Meeting of the Waters (Paper 1886) 701
    Treasury – Question No. 7 – 2000 – 2001 Tax Reform Savings Deducted (Paper 1933) (Mr Reed) 723
    Unlawful entry with intent (combined buildings and dwellings) total count using ABS
    counting rules (Paper 1935) (Mr Reed) 724
    Unleaded petrol prices at the pump – 15 June 2000 (obtained by phone) (Paper 1919) (Mr Burke) 721
    Youth Grants 1999/2000 Youth Festival Drug and Alcohol Free Entertainment Youth
    Development/Leadership (Paper 1929) (Mr Burke) 722

PETITIONS
    Mandatory sentencing legislation, repeal (442 petitioners) (Paper 1918) (Ms Martin) 721
    Mandatory Sentencing of Juvenile Offenders Bill 1999 , repeal immediately
    (102 petitioners) (Paper 1917) (Ms Martin) 721
    Responses
    No. 41 re establishment of a school to reduce children’s travel time from Three Bore,
    Camel Camp and Homestead (Paper 1865) 694

STATEMENTS
    Agriculture and Horticultural industry developments in Katherine region (Paper 1867) (Mr Palmer) 695
    APEC Trade Ministers Conference in Darwin (Paper 1906) (Mr Manzie) 711
    Corroboree 2000, Reconciliation papers (Mr Burke) 694
    Department of Local Government 1998/99 – Performance Report (Paper 1866) (Mrs Braham) 695
    Indonesia, changes for the better (Paper 1904) (Mr Burke) 711
    Museums and Art Galleries of the Northern Territory, Cultural and Scientific Research
    undertaken (Paper 1874) (Mr Adamson) 700
    NTETA role and directions of the Northern Territory’s Education and Training facility
    (Paper 1906) (Mr Lugg) 712
    Sale of the Northern Territory TAB (Paper 1873) (Mr Baldwin) 700

VISITORS
    Batchelor Institute Teacher Education students accompanied by their lecturer Mr Gerry Pancini. 699
    Kormilda College, year 11 students attached to the Legislative Assembly as part of the
    E-Team Program (Mr Speaker) 722
Last updated: 04 Aug 2016